Caption

Does giving people more choice always make them more motivated? Autonomy is one of the most important ideas in motivation research. Being able to experience our actions as voluntary and self-directed is generally associated with motivation and well-being. But cross-cultural psychology raises an interesting question: does autonomy always have to mean making a decision completely by yourself? A famous study by psychologists Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper explored this with Anglo-American and Asian-American children. The children completed activities under different choice conditions. Sometimes they chose for themselves. In other conditions, the choice was made for them, including by their mother. The Anglo-American children were especially motivated when they got to make their own choice. But the Asian-American children showed a different pattern. They were especially motivated when the choice was made by someone with whom they had a close relationship—their mother. Why? One explanation is that choice can carry different psychological meanings. In a more independent model of the self, choosing for yourself can represent individuality, agency, and personal preference. In a more interdependent model, however, decisions can be understood more relationally. Having input from someone you trust doesn’t necessarily have to feel like that person is controlling you. It can reflect connection and shared goals. That’s an important distinction for the workplace. Managers are often encouraged to give employees autonomy: choose your project, decide how to approach it, figure out what works for you. And autonomy absolutely can be valuable across cultures. But autonomy isn’t necessarily synonymous with being left completely alone to make every decision. If an employee frequently asks, “What do you think I should do?” that doesn’t automatically mean they lack confidence or initiative. Maybe they want more information. Maybe they value collaboration. Maybe they simply prefer making decisions through discussion with people they trust. The goal isn’t to assume someone’s preference based on their cultural background. It’s to recognize that people can experience choice, guidance, and collaboration differently—and then ask how they actually prefer to work. For some people, freedom means: “Let me decide.” For others, a meaningful decision might look more like: “Let’s figure this out together.” Which feels more motivating to you? #psychologyfacts #cultural #workplace #asian #careeradvice